situational Medium General

A colleague accidentally emails you a spreadsheet containing confidential salary information for your whole team. What would you do?

Scenario questions test judgment under uncertainty. Below is a sample answer for this one, the traps candidates fall into, and the probes interviewers follow up with.

A strong example answer

Containment comes first, before anything else. I would stop at what I had already glimpsed — no forwarding, copying, or discussing the file with anyone, including the colleagues whose names appear in it. Then I would reply to the sender immediately and neutrally: "This reached me by mistake. I have not shared it and I am deleting my copy — you may want to alert IT or HR." In a comparable situation, the sender had merged the wrong mailing list, and a fast heads-up let IT recall the message before it spread past a handful of people.

After that I would delete the file, confirm the deletion, and report the incident to HR or security myself rather than assuming the sender handled it — misdirected confidential data is usually a reportable incident, and my obligation is to the process, not to sparing a colleague embarrassment. Whatever I saw stays as if I had never seen it. Salary information changes nothing about how I work with those colleagues, and mentioning it later, even casually, would be its own breach. The principle is simple: contain fast, report properly, and treat their information exactly the way I want my own compensation treated.

A framework for your own answer

  • Situation: Note how the file reached you and why its contents are sensitive.
  • Task: State your obligations: contain it, do not share it, report it per policy.
  • Action: Walk through alerting the sender, deleting your copy, and reporting the incident through the proper channel.
  • Result: Close with the principle of treating others’ information the way you want yours treated.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Curiosity is the first failure — reading the whole file before deciding what to do with it.
  • Don't just delete it quietly and tell no one; at most companies this is a mandatory incident report.
  • Talking about the contents with affected colleagues creates a second breach of your own making.
  • What you saw can never resurface — not in your own negotiation, not in office gossip.

Follow-up questions to prepare for

A strong answer invites follow-ups — interviewers probe to check the reasoning holds up. Prepare for questions like:

  • Would you still report it if the sender begged you not to?
  • What if the file revealed you were underpaid compared to your peers?
  • How would you respond if a colleague later tried to gossip about the contents with you?

Related practice questions

Keep drilling with these, or browse the complete question bank.

Next up

Practice this question on the clock

Reading an answer and delivering one are different skills. Run a timed round and rate yourself.

Start a practice round

Next up

Interview coming up?

Have your post-interview follow-up email ready before you need it.

Follow-up email generator